Site Meter Time 4 Trans Justice » Blog Archive » Gender Identity vs. Sexual Orientation

Gender Identity vs. Sexual Orientation

by Joe Bechtel

I had to do it–I had to regurgitate this topic, didn’t I? :) But maybe it needs to be talked about over and over until everyone on this planet gets it–Gender Identity is NOT the same as Sexual Orientation! Let me repeat myself.  Gender Identity is NOT the same as Sexual Orientation!! Here’s why:

Sexual orientation is who you are attracted to, and Gender identity is who you identify as when it comes to gender. Pretty simple, huh? Apparently not, if so many people still confuse the two. Let me break it down further.
Gender Identity has nothing to do with a person’s genitals, but everything to do with how a person sees themselves–deep down in the core. Base identity. An example, when you were 4 years old, and you were born as a male, did you see yourself as a boy or a girl? And if you saw yourself as a boy, then there was no problem. But if you saw yourself as a girl, and wondered why people were treating you as a boy–big problem! This is gender identity–not sexual orientation.

Sexual orientation comes along a little later in people’s lives. It could show up around 7 or it could be a lot later, depending on how conservative of liberal the environment is. Humans are sexual creatures no matter what we believe, or how we want to approach it. And sexual preferences will come out–eventually. Who turns you on, when, and where are inevitable and will come out sooner or later. This is not the same as Gender Identity. This is about romantic feelings, some part of body chemistry, and who you choose as a life partner, whether it ends up being a same-sex union, or a hetero union. This is sexual orientation.

So–simple, right? Then why is it that when people find out I am transgender, they get all nervous and fidgety? I know–people don’t understand this, most people have no clue what it involves, what it is, etc. But then, there are the conservative Christians who shy away from me, because they lump it all into the “homosexual” category. It’s all sin according to the churches. Many churches are even silent about Transgender issues. Are they silent because they have no idea what it is, or are they silent because they simply assume it’s the same thing as homosexuality?

As a recap–gender identity is not the same as sexual orientation. If you can wrap your mind around this, it will do a lot for the issues that have stopped ENDA from including trans inclusive language, and for all the other issues I will be talking about here. Some gay men have actually been born in female bodies, who have transitioned to presenting as the gender they identified as. Some lesbian women have been born in male bodies, who have transitioned to presenting as the gender they identified as. Most transgender people start out appearing homosexual, but are completely straight–just in the wrong body presentation. Sexuality has nothing to do with gender identity–get that, and every other issue about Transgendered people will be pointless.


One Response to “Gender Identity vs. Sexual Orientation”

  1. Darkside Rainbow » Blog Archive » Remember, lest we forget. Says:

    [...] are concerned, because much of the general public doesn’t understand the concept of gender identity and its differences from sexual identity. They view crossdressing as a sexual fetish that often has to do with being gay, when that’s [...]

Leave a Reply


About Time 4 Trans Justice

Time 4 Trans Justice is justice for Transgendered individuals, as well as the Transgendered community. It’s about uniting the community in one voice to tell others that we will NOT take the crap they dish out to us anymore. It’s about seeing that we get the same rights as the rest of the human race get access to. It’s about time we get our issues to the forefront of society to give our issues and needs the attention they deserve.

Time 4 Trans Justice Author(s)
    » Joe-Bechtel

Gay & Lesbian Channel Posts

  • Clay Aiken's Gay
    So now that he's a daddy himself, now that five years of speculation have been swept under the rug, now that he's had a successful reprisal of his role as Sir Robin in Monty Python's Spamalot, now [...]
  • Halos and Horns - Brad Pitt Supports Gay Marriage
    You read the headline right.  Movie superstar heartthrob and Angelina Jolie baby daddy Brad Pitt is not only easy on the eyes and a pretty darned good actor, he also has a special place in his [...]
  • Funny Commercials
    I saw this today and couldn't resist sharing it.  I know I've been neglecting you, my pretties and I sincerely apologize from the bottom of my Sex on the Beach. Maybe this makes it up a little [...]
  • Will & Grace star auctions his car for AIDS Charity
    Actor Eric McCormack who played Will on the popular NBC television series Will & Grace is a big believer in giving back. According to a statement released recently, McCormack put his prized [...]
  • Michael's Big Gay Pride and Opinions Link Contest
    How's this for shameless self-promotion? I am hereby announcing the first-ever link contest here at Pride and Opinions! As we all know, web sites only grow when people know about them and I want [...]
  • Introducing the Pride and Opinions Blidget!
    I know your type. You're the early adopter, techno-geek who probably sat in line for three days to get the new iPhone 3G. Well now you've got something new to add to your web arsenal, in the form [...]
  • Alternative sexuality conference to be held November 8th in The Greater City of Sudbury, ON.
    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Sudbury, ON - September 1, 2008 - The Northern Ontario Conference of Kink (NOCK) will be held on November 8, 2008, from noon to midnight, in Chelmsford, ON, 25 minutes [...]
  • Michael's Gayest Albums Evar - Volume 1
    The current issue of OUT Magazine contains a cover piece touting the "100 Gayest Albums of All Time", so I thought I would take a look at some of what I consider to be the gayest of them [...]
  • Pride & Opinions Hurricane Party Music - Volume 1
    You know us gays - it doesn't take much for us to have a party.  In fact, sometimes we just have a party because there is nothing else to do. This time it seems as though Hurricane Gustav is [...]
  • Atlanta Gay Business Owner Arrested on Federal Charges
    Gay businessman Ben Elliott - who left the Atlanta area immediately after the controversial closing of popular gay bar Hoedown's last year - was arrested Wednesday on federal charges of wire fraud [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Brock's Wife Pregnant Confirmed, JR "Affordable" Holiday Offers
    JR has posted on his blog, here are a few snippets: JR has confirmed on Rena, brock's wife pregnant: Brock Lesnar and his pregnant wife Rena enjoyed the post fight festivities at a Japanese steak [...]
  • Brad and Angelina at Changeling London Photocall
    Angelina and Brad showed up at the Changeling London photocall this evening, looking...well...tired! I first looked at these pics and noticed that they look as worn down as any parents with [...]
  • The View November 17th Recap: Day of Hot Topics and David Frost
    Today on The View, Barbara Walters was present, but Sherri Shepherd was absent. She spent the weekend in Florida for "Super Soap" weekend. Whoopi Goldberg made that announcement using another [...]
  • Rural-Urban Divide and Election '08
    The following article was published earlier this year on the website of the History News Network. A Historian Reflects on the Rural-Urban Divide and Election '08 By Daniel Herman March, [...]
  • Free Digital Game Magazine
    Gamers will love this. D-PAD is a beautifully done and information packed free game magazine in digital format. You can download and read the free PDF format magazine at your leisure. Current [...]
  • Harrier women 4th, men 8th at NCAA West Region Championships
    The Arizona State University cross country team competed in the NCAA West Region Cross Country Championships Saturday afternoon on the Stanford Golf Course in Stanford, Calif., with the women taking [...]
  • Did Grey’s Jump the Shark?
    Ok, deep breath and let’s discuss last week’s episode. But first, let me say, I love Katherine Heigl. I love Jeffrey Dean Morgan. I loved the Izzie and Denny storyline from a few seasons ago. I [...]
  • Quotes from The Office Business Trip
    MICHAEL:     Meredith, I would like you to pretend that you are from Abu Dhabi. MEREDITH:     Hello... MICHAEL:     I am ashamed at [...]
  • Why HIV Treatment Makes People So Susceptible To Heart Disease And Diabetes
    Clinicians have known for some time that people treated for HIV also become much more susceptible to diabetes and heart disease. A study by scientists at Sydney's Garvan Institute of Medical Research [...]
  • 6 months
    My baby turned 6 months old last week but my laptop is dying so I can't write about it. I will try and write the proper post I intended later but right now I have to save all my photos to disc. [...]